The scissor jack that came with my 1991 Miata was built to change one tire on the shoulder of a road, one time, and then go back in the trunk and be forgotten. I used it for eleven years. Every oil change, every set of brake pads, every afternoon I wanted to get under the front end and look at something, out came that little crank handle and the stack of scrap plywood I kept behind the workbench.
It worked, which was the problem. It worked just well enough that I never bought anything better, and I spent a lot of Saturdays turning a crank forty times to lift a car four inches. Then one afternoon the plywood shifted. The car came down off the jack and I was standing clear, mostly by luck. I can still hear the sound it made on the concrete.
That was the week I started reading about floor jacks, and the one I kept coming back to was the ARCAN 3-Ton Aluminum Low Profile Floor Jack, model A20019. It is aluminum, it weighs 56 pounds, and it carries a 6,000 pound rating. I bought it for the low profile more than anything else. The Miata sits about as low as a car can sit, and I was tired of driving it up onto blocks just to reach the jacking point.
I should say up front that I am not a professional mechanic. I am a county water department supervisor in Sacramento who learned brakes and oil changes from his dad in a driveway in the 1980s, and I have been making weekend mistakes ever since. That is the seat I am writing from, and it is why I care more about the first ten minutes of a job than the last ten.
The first time I slid the ARCAN under the front crossmember I laughed out loud in an empty garage. No ramp. No block. No cursing. The saddle starts at 3.75 inches and rises to 18, and the jack comes with its handle, so there was nothing else to order.
The job did not get shorter because my wrenching got faster. It got shorter because getting the car into the air stopped being a project of its own.
Slides under a low car at 3.75 inches and lifts to 18
If your car sits low, that number is the whole pitch. The rest is a 56 pound aluminum jack rated for 6,000 pounds that does what the handle tells it.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →The truck told me more about the jack than the Miata did. My 2012 Tacoma has about 168,000 miles on it, and when I rotate the tires I want the front end up high and stable, not up high and hopeful. Eighteen inches of lift is enough to get my stands under the frame at a height where I can actually work instead of lying on my side squinting. The reinforced lift arm is what sold me on the truck side. Under load it does not twist or walk, and a jack that does not walk is a jack I am willing to trust my hands to.
The other thing I did not expect to care about is the valving. ARCAN builds in bypass and overload valves, and the plain-English version is that the jack has a limit it will not push past instead of letting you find out the hard way. I have never had a jack run away on me and I would like to keep that record intact. Knowing the ceiling is built into the hydraulics is worth more to me at 52 than it would have been at 30, when I was more confident and less careful.
It is also easy to live with in a small space. The footprint is 30 by 13.5 by 8 inches, so mine stands on its side against the wall between the rolling tool chest and the workbench, and I can carry it out to the driveway with one hand. A steel jack of the same capacity would live in the same corner and take up twice the room to do it.
What it did not do is fix my floor. A floor jack on a cracked, sloped slab is still a floor jack on a cracked, sloped slab. My concrete is sealed and reasonably flat, and I still chock the rear wheels, and I still put stands under the frame before any part of me goes underneath. The jack lifts. The stands hold. Nothing I bought this year changes that order of operations.
Two gripes, because I said I would be honest about this. The warranty runs one year, which is short for a tool that lives on a garage floor and gets rolled over grit. And at 56 pounds it is light enough to carry across a garage and heavy enough that I would not want to haul it up a flight of stairs. Neither one has cost me a minute of actual work.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
I would tell you the jack is not the interesting purchase. The interesting purchase is the one that removes the reason you keep putting a job off. I did not need more horsepower or a bigger compressor or another rolling cart. I needed to stop dreading the first ten minutes of every job, because those ten minutes were the reason a brake job turned into an entire weekend of not doing it.
I would also tell you to buy for the lowest vehicle you own, not the highest. The Miata is the reason I went with a low profile jack, and the Tacoma benefits from the same tool at no extra cost, since 18 inches of lift covers it comfortably. If you have one low car and one tall one, buy for the low one. And whatever you buy, buy stands with it. A jack lifts. It does not hold. Anyone who tells you otherwise has not been under a car when something slipped.
The tool that ended the plywood stack in my garage
3 tons of capacity, a 3.75 inch starting height, and a lift arm that does not wander under load. Read the listing, check the numbers against your own car, and keep your stands close.
Amazon See the ARCAN A20019 on Amazon →